No Cameras: politics, international humanitarian law, military theory and ferrets

[Previous entry: "Donald Rumsfeld - America's #1 enemy"] [Main Index] [Next entry: "Odd searches"]

06 July 2003: "A brief foray into Coulterism"

When I saw the advertisements announcing Ann Coulter's new book, Treason, several months ago, I initially thought it was a joke. I thought somebody had taken the ludicrous concept behind her earlier book Slander and driven it ad absurdum.

I suppose I should have known better. Ann Coulter doesn't need anybody else to make her look absurd.

The indispensable Spinsanity provides a quick overview of the book's general flaws, garnished with concrete examples. The short version of the book is that, in Coulter's opinion, any American who is not a Republican is nothing short of being a traitor to the United States. The only way this is a valid point of view is if you subscribe to the notion that the Party, the State and the People are one and the same, and that anyone who opposes the Party is therefore by definition an enemy of the State, and of the People. That's a pretty totalitarian way of thinking, even if it's not conscious.

It also goes to show that a legal opinion is not necessarily worth the paper it's printed on; Coulter was an attorney before she discovered there was more money to be made in taking cheap shots at the Clintons, yet she has blithely disregarded the definition of treason as set out in Article III, Section 3 of the Constitution of the United States of America in writing this book.

I have to wonder what the title of Coulter's next book could possibly be. I mean, how do you top accusing anyone who disagrees with you on anything of treason? About the only thing I can think of is Genocide, or perhaps Necrophilia. As Carl Skutsch put it in AntiCoulter:

Your opponents are not usually evil, they just see things differently than you do. And that's normal, even healthy. Coulter's dinner guest, John Lott, recognizes this. Elsewhere in Coulter's essay he tells her that liberals simply believe in 'different facts' than he does, and that makes them neither evil nor stupid. But Coulter doesn't get it.
In all fairness, it should pointed out this failing is not unique to Coulter, or limited to any particular part of the political spectrum. But she is a particularly illustrative example of this tendency.

Incidentally, Coulter's apparently going to start a blog. There goes the neighbourhood. Interestingly, the title—"CoulterGeist"—seems to be lifted from an article of the same name which appeared in the New York Observer in August 2002. Yes, she might think American journalists are "retarded" to a man (see same article), but that evidently won't stop her from appropriating their ideas. (Kudos to the folks at the Fametracker fora for digging up the latter stuff.)

I have to admit I harbour suspicions that Coulter doesn't write all, if any, of the stuff published under her name herself. It would certainly explain how she was able to put out two doorstops less than a year apart (though, of course, Treason shows no signs of any research whatsoever, which would cut down on the amount of time required) while also producing newspaper columns and making numerous television appearances. It might also go some way to explaining the mind-boggling amount of misogynism that goes into her material. In any given column, it is standard practice to cast aspersions on the masculinity of male subjects (usually involving the use of the adjective "girly," e.g. as in "girly-boy") while curiously, female subjects are ridiculed for being insufficiently "feminine" for displaying behaviour similar to that of the "girly-boys." (You work out the internal logic in that one.) So maybe Coulter does need other people to make her look absurd after all. If so, they're probably the same people who are writing Sean Hannity's stuff, which sounds suspiciously similar.
Navigation:
home
archives
backgrounder
e-mail

Blogs:

au currant
Black Decaf
The Illiterati
Cointelpro Tool
Norman Geras
A Fistful of Euros
Harry's Place
Plastic Gangster
Blogfonte
Tim Newman
€urosavant
Crooked Timber
Gallowglass
Mr. McGillicuddy
eameljenet
Civax
101-280
Colby Cosh
Peaktalk
Mick Hartley
Oliver Kamm

Miscellanea:

Isn't it time you went for analysis?

Radio Netherlands

Spinsanity: countering rhetoric with reason

EU Observer

Human Rights Watch

Dissent Magazine

3WA: home of the forbidden smiley

DamnHellAssKings: some of the finest sites on the web

Brunching Shuttlecocks

Washington Ferret Rescue & Shelter

The Brick Testament

Care to contribute
to the coffee fund?


� 2003-2004 Jurjen Smies